Do You Have to Be a Little Stupid to Be Great at Sales?
Are you too smart to sell? Find out why intelligence and nuance might be the hidden obstacles in your pitch.
There’s an irony playing out in startups, agencies, and creator studios everywhere. The person who knows the most about the thing is often the worst person to sell it. Not because they lack passion, but because they carry too much of it. They’ve seen the wiring behind the wall. They remember the version that broke in testing. They know what it can’t do, just as well as what it can.
This awareness becomes a weight in sales. It slows down your story. You start explaining instead of persuading, while someone with just enough understanding to be dangerous swoops in and says something like, “It just works.” And people believe them.
It isn’t stupidity. It’s not being caught in your own nuance. The less you think about how the value works, the easier it is to talk about why it matters.
Which leads us to the uncomfortable thought no one wants to say out loud: sometimes, the less you understand, the better you can sell.
Why Deep Understanding Can Kill Your Pitch
The more you know, the harder it is to speak in absolutes. You see too many variables, too many what-ifs. And when you're steeped in all that detail, it becomes difficult to offer a neat, confident promise. You want to tell the whole truth. You want to do it justice. You want people to know that you’re not one of those charlatans peddling a one-size-fits-all miracle.
So instead of saying, “It works,” you say, “Well, in most cases, assuming certain conditions are met and the client isn’t using a legacy system from 2007, it can deliver X.” You think you're building trust. What you're actually doing is building confusion.
Sales isn’t a courtroom. The buyer doesn’t want a full case file. They want a feeling of certainty. A sentence that makes sense. A reason to believe.
That’s why the person who knows less often sells more. Not because they’re smarter or slicker, but because they’re willing to keep it simple. They don’t carry the weight of every technical footnote. So when they say, “It helps you grow faster,” they say it without flinching.
This doesn’t make them dishonest. It makes them effective. Sales rewards clarity. The more intelligent you are, the more you tend to qualify your statements. And the more you qualify, the less persuasive you become.
The Advantage of Simplified Certainty
There’s a reason the best salespeople aren’t always the product experts. It’s not because they’re lazy or incapable. It’s because they understand that most people don’t want the entire blueprint. They want the one-liner. They want a feeling. They want something that makes immediate sense. This kind of simplicity takes skill.
When a salesperson picks a narrative and sticks to it, they’re doing something most analytically minded people struggle with: they’re choosing to highlight the part of the product that delivers the most obvious and tangible benefit. They’re trying to make someone care.
That’s the job. Make people care, quickly. Confuse them and you lose them.
This doesn’t mean salespeople are dishonest. It means they’re selective. And that’s the point. The product might be complex, but the message can’t be. To communicate value effectively, you need to choose your truth and commit to it. You need to quiet the part of your brain that wants to issue a disclaimer every time you speak.
Customers are looking for confidence. They want to know, in plain terms, how their life will be better after buying what you’re offering.
So when we say “a little bit stupid,” we really mean something else. We mean less entangled. More willing to be clear, even if it’s not comprehensive.
The “Obvious to You = Worthless to Others” Trap
Once you truly master something it stops feeling like a skill. What once required effort becomes second nature. You move through the motions instinctively. And then, when someone asks you to explain what you do, you freeze. It feels too simple. Too obvious. Too easy.
This is the “Obvious Trap,” and it sabotages countless smart people every day. When you’ve spent years refining a process, building a system, or designing a solution, the clarity you’ve earned starts to feel like something anyone could have stumbled across. You mistake the outcome of your expertise for a baseline level of understanding.
You start softening your pitch because you don’t think it’s “that valuable.” You lower your price because it only took you a few hours to create while ignoring the years of context that made that speed possible. You hesitate to promote it at all, because it doesn’t feel revolutionary anymore.
But that clarity is precisely what makes it valuable to others. It may feel effortless to you, but to someone else, it’s a shortcut they didn’t even know they needed.
This is why people who didn’t build the thing often sell it better. They haven’t spent a decade being worn down by proximity. They’re not tangled in the humility that tells you something has to be hard to be worthwhile.
They can see it for what it is: a solution. Not a masterpiece. Not a miracle. Just something that works.
Sales as Human Connection, Not Intellectual Debate
The suggestion that great salespeople might be “a little bit stupid” isn’t a dig. It’s a reframing of what intelligence looks like in a different context. When it comes to sales, success isn’t determined by how much you know. It’s shaped by how well you connect. And connection doesn’t reward encyclopedic knowledge.
The best salespeople aren’t necessarily the most technical in the room. They’re the ones who know how to read the moment. They can sense doubt in a pause. They know when to push and when to hold back. This isn’t fluff. These are real skills, and they’re harder to teach than bullet points about features and specs.
What moves people to buy is the feeling that someone understands what they want, even if they can’t fully articulate it themselves. The sale is a trust exchange. You are not just offering a solution. You are offering reassurance, confidence, alignment. A sense that they’ll be better off on the other side.
This is why belief matters. The more you try to explain every single part of why something works, the less certain it begins to feel. That’s the trap of overthinking. The most effective salespeople sidestep this entirely.
You don’t need to know everything. You need to care, and you need to believe. And sometimes, not being able to rattle off every technical detail is exactly what allows you to speak with the kind of clarity that creates trust.
So, do you really need to be a little bit stupid to sell well? Not exactly. But you may need to be less precious about your intelligence. In sales, too much nuance muddies the water.
What you likely need is to unlearn some of what makes you sharp in other contexts. Precision. Caution. These are great in research papers or product design. They are less useful when you have thirty seconds to make someone care.
What you sell, at its core, is belief. The confidence that something will work. That it will improve a life, a process, a bottom line. You are not selling the gears inside the watch. You are selling the feeling of knowing what time it is.
At StratEx - Indonesia Business Advisory we work with clients to identify and scope opportunities for AI adoption in the organisational design. Contact us if you're interested how AI can increase your organisational and human capital effectiveness.